Why your TV commercial should have a persistent brand watermark

August 31, 2020

What exactly makes a great ad? Making a powerful creative is both an art and a science, and at Tatari we provide guidance for both. Artistic aspects like tone and production quality are critical to a great creative, but difficult to objectively isolate and measure. In this article, we discuss the quantitative aspects and focus on the more objective binary features that can be tested for impact on creative performance.

In addition to examining creative de-bias for each client, another method we use to understand what makes an ad creative perform is tagging specific elements (e.g. coupon code, persistent brand watermark, etc.) in every creative that is aired across all our clients. We then look for all creatives that have the same tag and see if it is correlated with (strong) performance.

Some of these tested features can drive a 20% higher lift. While we won’t unveil all of them in this post, we will discuss one which has been effective for 70% of Tatari clients who have tested it: brand watermarking! See table below.

Across all A/B tests conducted, the insertion of a brand watermark has been effective for 70% of Tatari clients, with an average response lift of 8% for creatives.

Why does it generally work? People may be partially distracted or even mute the volume on their TV, and in some cases, viewers could lose interest before the brand name is shown. Also, memories are fallible and visually linking the brand name throughout the spot can engrain a connection between the product and the brand. Finally, in some cases a brand of URL might not have the expected spelling. For example, brand XYZ might have the URL: www.buyXYZ.com. The persistent URL will help avoid having a frustrated potential buyer give up before making a purchase.

How the brand watermark is executed is also important. Displaying a banner with the brand name and website URL at the bottom of the screen is correlated with lower response. Possibly that owes to pulling the viewer’s attention away from the body of the spot and also requires more mental processing The lower response may also owe to an association with stereotypical lower quality “Call Now!” infomercial-type ads.

We recommend creative testing to continuously improve creatives. Including a creative with a brand watermark is a simple yet likely effective option for such a test, but it’s just one of many more elements that we examine (using quantitative data & analysis) with our clients and their production agencies. 

Param Dhillon

I like science, data, and roller derby.

Related

Video: Leading growth marketers discuss TV as a performance channel

We were recently joined by leading growth marketers, Junior Reyes (Resident), Aaron Pelander (GovX), and Dan Guy (Lemonaid Health) to discuss how they’re utilizing TV as a performance channel.

Harvesting the power from granular TV advertising data exports

Many brands use granular advertising data to perform deep analysis & help them optimize multi-channel advertising strategies. Here are a few ways you can use raw TV data to optimize advertising strategies.  

Frequency capping in streaming TV campaigns

Being able to target customers with the optimal number of views and minimize CPV (and CAC) is a unique advantage of streaming TV, yet the opportunity gets squandered.